A New Paradigm For Bali’s Tourism Industry

A New Paradigm For Bali's Tourism Industry
Paradigm shift for Bali
Image by Arek Socha from Pixabay.

In a recent meeting at the Bank Indonesia (BI) Provincial Representative Office in Bali, key stakeholders in Bali’s tourism industry got together to discuss ‘Quality and Sustainability: A New Paradigm of Bali Cultural Tourism’.

According to Bali Post, the development and sustainability of Bali’s culture was a key factor in discussions around ways to improve the standards of quality and sustainability in Bali’s tourism industry.

Nangun Sat Kerthi Loka Bali

This was explained through a vision of something called ‘Nangun Sat Kerthi Loka Bali’.

This concept aims to tap into the values and wisdom of the Balinese by maintaining a balance between nature, social groups and local culture. The hope is to be able to meet the needs, hopes and aspirations of the Balinese in a variety of aspects of life while at the same time being sufficiently prepared to deal with national and global challenges.

Dr. Panudiana Kuhn, one of the initiators of the event and a speaker focused on ‘quality tourism’ say Bali Post, suggested this meant accommodating quality tourists to improve destinations. “Measuring that quality is knowing how far they contribute to the local community,” he said. “Quality tourism must be made into an ideology, that is, protection of resources, and the community must also benefit.”

What does quality mean?

But what does quality, or the perception of quality, actually mean?

David A. Garvin from Harvard University wrote an interesting article for Sloan Management Review a few years ago around the concept of quality.

While the article is very academic and not specifically around tourism and hospitality, his well researched and informative piece presents some very logical and important approaches to defining quality, which I think, can easily be adapted to Bali’s tourism industry. Stakeholders might want to take note.

Garvin suggests there are five basic approaches to determine quality:

  1. Transcendent
  2. Product based
  3. User based
  4. Business based
  5. Value based

The transcendent approach

This suggests that quality is indefinable, like beauty.

We recognize it from experience and there is universal recognition of innate excellence, uncompromising standards and high achievement.

Many of Bali’s award winning 5-Star hotels for example, would fall in to this category.

The product based approach

This is different. This approach suggests quality is an inherent characteristic of something.

It is both precise and measurable and is linked to specific attributes, which most people will pay more for because they associate those characteristics with higher prices.

Again, some of Bali’s hotels and resorts would fall into this space as would paying a premium for organic food and Eco-conscious accommodation.

The user based approach

This approach is very subjective and comes from the idea that ‘quality lies in the eyes of the beholder’.

Everyone is different and has different needs. Things that satisfy these needs are therefore considered to be quality. It’s a difficult marketing conundrum, but the assumption is high-quality products are those that satisfy the needs of most of the customers, but this also means something that’s preferable isn’t necessarily better.

The business based approach

This is not subjective and it’s not based around market/ consumer wants and needs.

In this approach, quality means “conformance to requirements” from a business perspective. Excellence means meeting specifications. In this model, quality means fewer deviations from the specifications and therefore costs are reduced.

In many respects, this fits closest to the vision of ‘Nangun Sat Kerthi Loka Bali.’

The value based approach

This takes the business based approach to an extreme because with this idea, quality is only about costs and prices.

Here performance at an acceptable cost is the way to go. The problem with this is quality as a measure of excellence is equated with cost as a measure of worth. It leads to something called “affordable excellence.”

Some of the all-in-one warehouse shops selling souvenirs on Sunset might well fall into this category.

Fundamental differences

Marketing and branding people tend to follow user-based approaches. This is where customers determine what is quality and what’s not. In this way of thinking, higher quality generally means being better and that means more expensive.

That’s why we see high-end advertising for high-cost experiences and services.

Business folk, on the other hand believe quality is all about meeting certain specifications because if they meet these, costs will be lower. The end product might not be what people want and it may not be expensive, but because it meets the company’s specifications/ requirements it makes more money.

Many ways to get there

The upshot of this is that there are many ways to define quality and we need to be aware of them.

Garvin suggests one way to do this would be to use more than one approach and to find balance, maybe by conducting market research (which is the user based approach) and use the results to identify specific attributes (which is the product based approach.)

The business approach would then take both of these aspects to ensure the final product matches both sets of requirements as best it can.

Garvin argues there are many dimensions that go to defining the basic elements of quality including performance, features, reliability, aesthetics, service and perception.

Some of these can be measured, others can’t as they are based on individual preference. Some are ‘objective and timeless’ while others change with fashions and trends.

Because there are so many ways to define quality it’s all but impossible to cover them all and segmentation is inevitable.

What’s the focus?

When Bali’s tourism industry proclaims it wants to focus on quality rather than quantity it has to actually mean something. It could, for example, focus on performance and features, or it could focus on aesthetics and the perception of its target markets or it could focus on service and standards. Maybe it wants to focus on everything.

Whatever path it takes, the industry needs to be clear about what it’s doing, who it’s doing it for, how it’s going to do it and why it’s doing it in the first place.

And hopefully the answer won’t be just to make more money because that is short-term and it just won’t work! Read some Simon Sinek to understand that. That’s not to say you shouldn’t want to make more money – every business does. But making money is a result, it’s not why you do it.

Garvin references Peter Reisz as saying that if perceptions and consumer decisions are correlated to price (that means it’s high quality and therefore expensive … and because it’s expensive it must be high quality) there is a danger of setting inflated prices to suggest quality is higher.

Spoiler alert folks – this is simply not sustainable.

Brand Bali has to deliver

In my opinion, two things have to be taken very seriously in discussions around tourism in Bali:

  1. Bali’s brand and marketing has to be re-thought and upgraded to better reflect this idea of quality tourism. This doesn’t mean just changing the logo and having a new slogan. Research needs to be done, strategies have to be developed and awareness must be created.
  2. When the brand and advertising campaigns successfully attract a particular market segment, the perceptions and experiences of why people decided to come here must have value and have to be realized. It is critical that customer satisfaction be understood and changes made to better suit the ultimate goals.

If these aspects are ignored, then in my humble opinion, there’s a real danger of inflated prices for poor quality products and services. Unfortunately, that could be a the start of a slippery slope down a dead-end street to disappointment for Bali’s tourism industry.

But if it’s done right, and this paradigm shift is understood, it could be a very positive direction for the industry to take, especially as global travel trends are all pointing in the direction of meaningful, Eco-conscious experiences. And in this regard, Bali has everything to offer and much to gain.

Sources: Bali Post, Gapura Bali, Antara News, Sloan Management Review, Journal of Consumer Affairs

#bali #tourism #paradigmshift #quality #baliculture

Latest Article
Recruiting Foreign Doctors Will Improve Health Services
Emanuel Melkiades Laka Lena, a member of Indonesia’s House of Representatives (DPR), has said that the...
Indonesia Proposes Visa-Free Entry for 20 Countries to Boost Tourism and Economy
In December 2023, Indonesia’s Ministry of Tourism and Creative Economy  proposed visa-free access...
Top 5 Most Visited Provinces by Foreign Tourists in Sumatra
  Bali, Lombok, and Raja Ampat certainly capture the tourism spotlight. However, Indonesia boasts...
Ministry: Immigration Services Restored
Indonesia’s Law and Human Rights Ministry’s Director General of Immigration, Silmy Karim, has announced...
More Than 1 Million Tourist Visits in April
According to reporting from Antara News, Indonesia’s Ministry of Tourism and Creative Economy announced...

Andrzej Barski

Director of Seven Stones Indonesia

Andrzej is Co-owner/ Founder and Director of Seven Stones Indonesia. He was born in the UK to Polish parents and has been living in Indonesia for more than 33-years. He is a skilled writer, trainer and marketer with a deep understanding of Indonesia and its many cultures after spending many years travelling across the archipelago from North Sumatra to Irian Jaya.

His experience covers Marketing, Branding, Advertising, Publishing, Real Estate and Training for 5-Star Hotels and Resorts in Bali and Jakarta, which has given him a passion for the customer experience. He’s a published author and a regular contributor to local and regional publications. His interests include conservation, eco-conscious initiatives, spirituality and motorcycles. Andrzej speaks English and Indonesian.

Terje H. Nilsen

Director of Seven Stones Indonesia

Terje is from Norway and has been living in Indonesia for over 20-years. He first came to Indonesia as a child and after earning his degree in Business Administration from the University of Agder in Norway, he moved to Indonesia in 1993, where he has worked in leading positions in education and the fitness/ wellness industries all over Indonesia including Jakarta, Banjarmasin, Medan and Bali.

He was Co-owner and CEO of the Paradise Property Group for 10-years and led the company to great success. He is now Co-owner/ Founder and Director of Seven Stones Indonesia offering market entry services for foreign investors, legal advice, sourcing of investments and in particular real estate investments. He has a soft spot for eco-friendly and socially sustainable projects and investments, while his personal business strengths are in property law, tourism trends, macroeconomics, Indonesian government and regulations. His personal interests are in sport, adventure, history and spiritual experiences.

Terje’s leadership, drive and knowledge are recognised across many industries and his unrivalled network of high level contacts in government and business spans the globe. He believes you do good and do well but always in that order. Terje speaks English, Indonesian and Norwegian.

Contact Our Consultants

[wpforms id=”43785″]

Ridwan Jasin Zachrie

CFO of Seven Stones Indonesia, Jakarta

Ridwan is one of Indonesia’s top executives with a long and illustrious career in the financial world. He holds several professional certifications including being a Certified Business Valuer (CBV) issued by the Australian Academy of Finance and Management; Broker-Dealer Representative (WPPE); and The Directorship Certification for Directors and Commissioners, issued by the Indonesian Institute of Commissioners and Directors.

His experience includes being the Managing Director at one of the top investment banking groups in the region, the Recapital Group, the CFO at State-owned enterprises in fishery industry and the CEO at Tanri Abeng & Son Holding. He’s also been an Independent Commissioner in several Financial Service companies and on the Audit and Risk Committee at Bank BTPN Tbk, Berau Coal Energy Tbk, Aetra Air Jakarta as well as working for Citibank, Bank Mandiri and HSBC. His last position was as CFO at PT Citra Putra Mandiri – OSO Group.

Ridwan has won a number of prestigious awards including the Best CFO Awards 2019 (Institute of Certified Management Accountant Australia-Indonesia); Asia Pacific Young Business Leader awarded by Asia 21 Network New York USA (Tokyo 2008); UK Alumni Business Awards 2008 awarded by the British Council; and The Most Inspiring Human Resources Practitioners’ version of Human Capital Magazine 2010.

He’s a member of the Board of Trustees of the Alumni Association of the Faculty of Law, Trisakti University, Co-Founder of the Paramadina Public Policy Institute and actively writes books, publications and articles in the mass media. He co-authored “Korupsi Mengorupsi Indonesia” in 2009, which helps those with an interest in understanding governance in Indonesia and the critical issue of corruption. Ridwan speaks Indonesian and English.

Per Fredrik Ecker

Managing Director of Seven Stones Indonesia, Jakarta

Per is the Managing Director of the Seven Stones Indonesia (SSI) Jakarta office and has more than 25-years’ experience in Indonesia, China, and Western Europe. He previously worked in senior management positions with Q-Free ASA, Siemens AG, and other companies in the telecom sector. Over the last six years, he has been the Chairman of the Indonesia-Norway Business Council (INBC) and recently become elected to be on the board of EuroCham Indonesia.

His most recent experience is within Intelligent Transport Solutions (ITS), Telecom, and other sectors within the Indonesian market. He is today through his position in SSI and by representing Norway Connect, promoting Nordic and European companies that would like to explore business opportunities in the Indonesian market. He’s also playing an active role to help create the Nordic House concept in Jakarta that will provide an excellent platform for Nordic companies entering Indonesia, where they’ll find a community that can offer support with trusted information and affordable services to enter this market.